As tensions rise, Mideast tourism sustains injuries
Tourism was among the victims
last week as conflict and tensions across North Africa and the Middle East
surged, capped by violent clashes between opposing factions in Syria and Egypt.
One look at the week's headlines -- violence in Syria, arrests in Egypt, Israel threatening to quash Iran's nuclear program -- and it was clear that retailers, suppliers and tourism boards dedicated to promoting and selling North Africa and the Middle East faced a daunting public relations crisis.
"There's always a correlation between media coverage and bookings," said Malia Asfour, director of the Jordan Tourism Board North America.
Jordan, where tourism accounts for 14% of gross domestic product, saw tourist arrivals from the U.S., its No. 1 source market, drop 12.9% in 2011 compared with 2010. (Click here to view of a map of the drop in U.S. arrivals in select Middle East countries.)
Jordan, which has experienced relative peace and calm of late and was hoping to emerge from its 2011 tourism slump this year, is exemplary of how damaging it can be to reside in the wrong neighborhood.
"I'm hopeful that 2012 is going to be better than 2011," Asfour said. "I'm counting on 2013 [tourism numbers] being back to 2010."
Jordan borders Syria, for which the U.S. Department of State on
Feb. 6 issued a travel warning advising U.S. citizens to leave Syria immediately
due to escalating violence and a deteriorating security situation there. The
same day, the State Department suspended all embassy operations after a
particularly bloody weekend. News media reported more than 200 deaths due to
violence in the city of Homs, a figure cited by opposition groups that have been
rising up against the government of President Bashar al-Assad since March 2011.
While Syria is not a dominant tourism destination in the region, the clashes come just as the country had been starting to improve its tourism profile and increasingly attract visitors. Between 2005 and 2010, Syria saw a 14% year-over-year growth rate in tourism, according to the Ministry of Tourism.
Meanwhile, tensions in Egypt, one of the region's most mainstream tourist destinations, have also been escalating. Last week, Egyptian authorities announced that 19 Americans working for nongovernmental organizations would be prosecuted, prompting the U.S. to threaten to withhold $1.5 billion in annual aid aimed at helping Egypt transition to democracy.
That threat followed news reports that two female U.S. tourists and their Egyptian guide had been kidnapped by armed men in Egypt's Sinai Peninsula, then later released.
"Anyone who tells you that Egypt business is up is obviously being facetious," said Ashish Sanghrajka, president of Big Five Tours & Expeditions. Sanghrajka said Big Five's Egypt business was still off pre-revolution, 2010 levels by a "considerable amount."
Egypt's tourism industry suffered a major blow in 2011 following the at-times violent Jan. 25 revolution, which resulted in the ouster of former president Hosni Mubarak. The country welcomed about 54% fewer U.S. tourists in 2011 than in 2010, according to the Egyptian Tourist Authority.
And while prospects for 2012 appear brighter than 2011, "right now, with Egypt, it really is day to day," Sanghrajka said. "There's definitely a demand for Egypt. We're getting calls from people who want to go, but they're being very cautious. They're just waiting for the elections. They're waiting for all of [the political strife] to subside."
Indeed, as with Jordan, those who sell Egypt last week were predicting a recovery toward the end of this year and into 2013.
"Egypt is hurting," said Abercrombie & Kent CEO Geoffrey Kent. Nevertheless, he predicted, "Egypt will come back."
Kent said he anticipates a turnaround by this time next year.
Bright spots amid turmoil
Despite the unrest and uprisings, not all destinations in the region have been hit equally hard. For example, agents and tour operators report positive bookings to Israel, Turkey and Morocco.
"I find that my people that go to Israel, they're going anyway, regardless of what's going on, and there are many people like that," said Pamela Jacobs, a vacation planner at Los Angeles-based TravelStore who is bullish on the region.
"There are things in the Middle East that are nowhere else in the world, and there are people that are going to go see them," Jacobs said.
Israel welcomed 3.4 million tourists in 2011, compared with 3.45 million in 2010, which Haim Gutin, the Israel Tourism Ministry's tourism commissioner for North and South America, described as "pretty incredible in view of the Arab Spring on top of the global economic downturn. Tourism to Israel from the U.S. fell 6%, to 611,000, in 2011 compared to 650,000 U.S. travelers in 2010."
Gutin added: "The concept of 'Who is still going?' is just so far from reality. The hotels are as full as they normally are in February, restaurants are bursting, flights are full and all is completely unchanged."
Sanghrajka said that Morocco has actually benefited from the displacement of travelers to places like Egypt.
"Morocco is where we've been surprised," Sanghrajka said. "There has been a tremendous increase in inquiries and bookings."
Turkey, too, appears to have successfully removed itself from the negative press of its neighbors to the south.
"We do terrific business with Turkey," said John Burgess, manager of the leisure travel division at Preferred Travel in Naples, Fla. "That hasn't been affected in the least."
And there are travelers who will continue to travel to Egypt and Jordan, regardless of tensions.
For example, A&K said it sees three categories of Americans that are still determined to head to these destinations no matter what: politically aware travelers who want to show support for the democracy movement; returning travelers who want to be among the first to see the newly restored Avenue of the Sphinxes in Luxor; and first-time travelers attracted by the exceptional values.
A bumpy road ahead
It's impossible to predict just where all the hostility and political wrangling in the Middle East is headed. In the meantime, parts of the tourism industry that are invested in the region find themselves in wait-and-see mode.
"We're not yet seeing a full recovery to the region, but we are seeing a few positive signs," noted Mike Schields, managing director for groups and emerging markets at the Globus family of brands.
Globus is projecting that it will be flat overall for the Middle East in 2012, he said.
"It's still relatively early in our booking year, so that could change," he said. "Egypt is down fairly substantially from the pace it was on in 2010, but we're seeing increases in business to Israel and Jordan, both religious and secular [travel], to offset that difference."
Despite everything, Globus remains "bullish on the region," according to a company statement, having even introduced a new six-day Wonders of Jordan product for 2012. "We have plans to expand our vacation offering even more in the coming year," the company stated.
A key turning point, Sanghrajka said, will be the presidential elections in Egypt in June.
"What has to happen now is these elections, and they need to actually go through and finish the process," he said. "We can all stand here on the side and cringe in terms of who comes into power, but we can't control that. What tourists have to see is that the will of the people is being done."
Sanghrajka said that once the elections have been held, there will be an acceleration in the return of tourists.
In the meantime, Burgess said, "Honestly, I wouldn't go [to the region] now. It's a comfort issue. The most important aspect of a client-agent relationship is trust. I've had a couple people ask if I would go now, and I've been perfectly honest: I wouldn't."
One look at the week's headlines -- violence in Syria, arrests in Egypt, Israel threatening to quash Iran's nuclear program -- and it was clear that retailers, suppliers and tourism boards dedicated to promoting and selling North Africa and the Middle East faced a daunting public relations crisis.
"There's always a correlation between media coverage and bookings," said Malia Asfour, director of the Jordan Tourism Board North America.
Jordan, where tourism accounts for 14% of gross domestic product, saw tourist arrivals from the U.S., its No. 1 source market, drop 12.9% in 2011 compared with 2010. (Click here to view of a map of the drop in U.S. arrivals in select Middle East countries.)
Jordan, which has experienced relative peace and calm of late and was hoping to emerge from its 2011 tourism slump this year, is exemplary of how damaging it can be to reside in the wrong neighborhood.
"I'm hopeful that 2012 is going to be better than 2011," Asfour said. "I'm counting on 2013 [tourism numbers] being back to 2010."
Jordan borders Syria, for which the U.S. Department of State on
Feb. 6 issued a travel warning advising U.S. citizens to leave Syria immediately
due to escalating violence and a deteriorating security situation there. The
same day, the State Department suspended all embassy operations after a
particularly bloody weekend. News media reported more than 200 deaths due to
violence in the city of Homs, a figure cited by opposition groups that have been
rising up against the government of President Bashar al-Assad since March 2011.
While Syria is not a dominant tourism destination in the region, the clashes come just as the country had been starting to improve its tourism profile and increasingly attract visitors. Between 2005 and 2010, Syria saw a 14% year-over-year growth rate in tourism, according to the Ministry of Tourism.
Meanwhile, tensions in Egypt, one of the region's most mainstream tourist destinations, have also been escalating. Last week, Egyptian authorities announced that 19 Americans working for nongovernmental organizations would be prosecuted, prompting the U.S. to threaten to withhold $1.5 billion in annual aid aimed at helping Egypt transition to democracy.
That threat followed news reports that two female U.S. tourists and their Egyptian guide had been kidnapped by armed men in Egypt's Sinai Peninsula, then later released.
"Anyone who tells you that Egypt business is up is obviously being facetious," said Ashish Sanghrajka, president of Big Five Tours & Expeditions. Sanghrajka said Big Five's Egypt business was still off pre-revolution, 2010 levels by a "considerable amount."
Egypt's tourism industry suffered a major blow in 2011 following the at-times violent Jan. 25 revolution, which resulted in the ouster of former president Hosni Mubarak. The country welcomed about 54% fewer U.S. tourists in 2011 than in 2010, according to the Egyptian Tourist Authority.
And while prospects for 2012 appear brighter than 2011, "right now, with Egypt, it really is day to day," Sanghrajka said. "There's definitely a demand for Egypt. We're getting calls from people who want to go, but they're being very cautious. They're just waiting for the elections. They're waiting for all of [the political strife] to subside."
Indeed, as with Jordan, those who sell Egypt last week were predicting a recovery toward the end of this year and into 2013.
"Egypt is hurting," said Abercrombie & Kent CEO Geoffrey Kent. Nevertheless, he predicted, "Egypt will come back."
Kent said he anticipates a turnaround by this time next year.
Bright spots amid turmoil
Despite the unrest and uprisings, not all destinations in the region have been hit equally hard. For example, agents and tour operators report positive bookings to Israel, Turkey and Morocco.
"I find that my people that go to Israel, they're going anyway, regardless of what's going on, and there are many people like that," said Pamela Jacobs, a vacation planner at Los Angeles-based TravelStore who is bullish on the region.
"There are things in the Middle East that are nowhere else in the world, and there are people that are going to go see them," Jacobs said.
Israel welcomed 3.4 million tourists in 2011, compared with 3.45 million in 2010, which Haim Gutin, the Israel Tourism Ministry's tourism commissioner for North and South America, described as "pretty incredible in view of the Arab Spring on top of the global economic downturn. Tourism to Israel from the U.S. fell 6%, to 611,000, in 2011 compared to 650,000 U.S. travelers in 2010."
Gutin added: "The concept of 'Who is still going?' is just so far from reality. The hotels are as full as they normally are in February, restaurants are bursting, flights are full and all is completely unchanged."
Sanghrajka said that Morocco has actually benefited from the displacement of travelers to places like Egypt.
"Morocco is where we've been surprised," Sanghrajka said. "There has been a tremendous increase in inquiries and bookings."
Turkey, too, appears to have successfully removed itself from the negative press of its neighbors to the south.
"We do terrific business with Turkey," said John Burgess, manager of the leisure travel division at Preferred Travel in Naples, Fla. "That hasn't been affected in the least."
And there are travelers who will continue to travel to Egypt and Jordan, regardless of tensions.
For example, A&K said it sees three categories of Americans that are still determined to head to these destinations no matter what: politically aware travelers who want to show support for the democracy movement; returning travelers who want to be among the first to see the newly restored Avenue of the Sphinxes in Luxor; and first-time travelers attracted by the exceptional values.
A bumpy road ahead
It's impossible to predict just where all the hostility and political wrangling in the Middle East is headed. In the meantime, parts of the tourism industry that are invested in the region find themselves in wait-and-see mode.
"We're not yet seeing a full recovery to the region, but we are seeing a few positive signs," noted Mike Schields, managing director for groups and emerging markets at the Globus family of brands.
Globus is projecting that it will be flat overall for the Middle East in 2012, he said.
"It's still relatively early in our booking year, so that could change," he said. "Egypt is down fairly substantially from the pace it was on in 2010, but we're seeing increases in business to Israel and Jordan, both religious and secular [travel], to offset that difference."
Despite everything, Globus remains "bullish on the region," according to a company statement, having even introduced a new six-day Wonders of Jordan product for 2012. "We have plans to expand our vacation offering even more in the coming year," the company stated.
A key turning point, Sanghrajka said, will be the presidential elections in Egypt in June.
"What has to happen now is these elections, and they need to actually go through and finish the process," he said. "We can all stand here on the side and cringe in terms of who comes into power, but we can't control that. What tourists have to see is that the will of the people is being done."
Sanghrajka said that once the elections have been held, there will be an acceleration in the return of tourists.
In the meantime, Burgess said, "Honestly, I wouldn't go [to the region] now. It's a comfort issue. The most important aspect of a client-agent relationship is trust. I've had a couple people ask if I would go now, and I've been perfectly honest: I wouldn't."
No comments:
Post a Comment